
It Always Comes Back to Calcutta
See the
Madwoman's
spaghetti map
Go to The Madwoman's
Marginalia

The Witness
I don't often dream in pictures.
My dreams have shape. Texture. Weight. They move through me much the way music does, occupying spaces I couldn't draw if you put a pencil in my hand.
But I remember the feeling of a voice. Its shape. Its texture. It's like a fingerprint. Everyone's textures and curves are slightly different from everyone else's. His voice, in particular, has always had a way of grounding me. Something familiar in its contours. The way it settled somewhere beneath my ribs.
"You are my magenta."
And somewhere in that strange architecture of knowing without seeing, another thought arrived, fully formed.
The blueprints are yellow.
I don't remember being shown them. I simply knew.
And when I woke, all I could think was his name.
There are things about dreaming that I find impossible to explain.
People talk about dreams as though they're films. Scenes stitched together by a sleeping brain with absolutely no respect for continuity. People appear. Places change. The dead walk through familiar rooms. Someone you haven't thought about in twenty years is suddenly working the register at a grocery store.
Mine aren't usually like that.
Or perhaps they are, and my brain simply refuses to preserve them that way.
I can remember the shape of an experience without remembering what happened. I can remember the pressure of something moving through a space I couldn't possibly describe. Sometimes there are colors. Sometimes there are textures. Sometimes there is only the absolute certainty of knowing something I have no memory of learning.
It's remarkably similar to the way I hear music. And just as difficult to explain to someone who doesn't.
I don't know what magenta was doing in my dream. I know what was said. I know how the voice felt. I know that the blueprints were yellow, despite having no recollection of ever seeing a blueprint.
And I know what happened when I woke.
His name.
Not a face. Not a conversation. Not even a memory.
Just his name, occupying the entirety of my conscious thought.
I lay there with it. And eventually, as I tend to do when something refuses to leave me alone, I started pulling at the threads.
I looked up the spiritual meaning of magenta.
There it was: the union of opposites. Integration. Transformation. Wholeness.
I don't know whether any of that has anything to do with what I dreamed. Symbolism is a slippery thing, and the human brain is spectacularly talented at finding significance after the fact. But the word wholeness caught. Because I knew where I'd heard it before.
Not in a dream.
In Calcutta.
I have lost count of how many times I've returned to this song. Not necessarily to listen to it, although I've done plenty of that.
I mean returned to it in the course of trying to understand something else.
I'll be somewhere entirely different in the body of work, pulling apart a word, following a grammatical oddity, examining a contradiction, and suddenly there's Calcutta again. Sitting there like it never left.
I've developed a habit of saying it aloud:
It always comes back to Calcutta.
It's become something of a running joke with myself.
Except the joke keeps getting less funny.
Not because I believe the song is hiding some grand answer. I've learned enough from this work to be suspicious of answers that arrive too conveniently. But because every time I return, I seem to notice something I couldn't see before.
And this time, I hadn't even been listening.
I'd been dreaming.
In Calcutta, the speaker wakes while saying someone's name.
There is no explanation of what preceded that moment. No explicit account of the dream, if there was one. No confirmation of what saying the name accomplishes.
Just the transition.
Waking.
Naming.
And there I was, lying in my own bed, with a name lodged in my head and very little else I could translate into words. I am not suggesting the song and my dream are connected by anything more mysterious than the spaghetti my own mind makes.
But I am interested in what happens when art gives language to an experience you haven't yet had.
Or perhaps to one you've had a hundred times without knowing how to describe it.
There is something else about Calcutta that has bothered me for a long time.
Its insistence on again.
Time is lived again.
Wholeness is experienced again.
But only temporarily.
The language establishes recurrence without explaining its mechanism. Something has happened before. Something is happening now. Whatever has been recovered is not promised permanence.
And the missing pieces? They find the speaker. Not the other way around.
I can't help but to keep coming back to that. There is a difference between searching for something you've lost and being found by something you didn't know was missing.
I know what it is to go looking for answers. I know what it is to build elaborate structures around questions because I cannot stand leaving them unanswered.
Blueprints, perhaps. Plans for making sense of things that refuse to make sense.
But I also know what it is to have something arrive without asking for it.
A thought.
A feeling.
A voice.
A name.
And suddenly the careful architecture I've constructed around myself doesn't seem quite as stable as I thought. I don't know what the yellow blueprints meant. I'm not going to pretend I do. But I find it interesting that my dreaming mind gave me a statement about plans, while my waking mind gave me something I couldn't have planned at all.
And then there is Fields of Elation.
Because, as it turns out, Calcutta wasn't the first place I'd encountered this particular arrangement of things. In Fields, the daylight is disappearing. Time is being buried. The speaker is caught somewhere that nobody else seems capable of pulling them out of.
And there is a name. A name described as a sin.
I have spent an extraordinary amount of time thinking about that particular choice of words. Not because I believe the song establishes some universal prohibition against speaking it. It doesn't. But because a name is ordinarily such a simple thing: A handful of sounds arranged to distinguish one person from another.
Until it isn't.
Until the act of knowing someone's name carries a weight that has very little to do with the sounds themselves. And then, in Calcutta, the speaker wakes saying a name.
I keep returning to the distance between those two moments.
One song places a name inside a world of receding daylight, buried hours, and an inability to be pulled out. The other places the act of naming at the threshold of waking.
I cannot establish that they are the same name. Or even that the songs describe the same experience. But I can point to the language. And I can ask what changes between a name being characterized as sinful and a name being spoken aloud.
There is another detail I can't quite leave alone:
In Fields, nobody else can pull the speaker out.
In Calcutta, the missing pieces find the speaker.
That doesn't necessarily mean anyone has escaped anything. Being found is not the same as being pulled free. And the wholeness that follows in Calcutta is temporary anyway.
Just a moment.
Something recovered, or perhaps merely experienced again, before the morning comes.
I find myself wondering whether it's possible to feel whole without ever having left the place that made you feel divided.
Whether something can reach you there. Whether the return of a feeling is the same thing as the return of what caused it.
I don't know.
But I know what it feels like to recognize something before I understand it. I know what it feels like to hear a voice and recognize its shape before my mind has done the work of turning sensation into language. And I know what it feels like to wake with a name.
His name.
Not a face. Not an explanation. Not a story I could reconstruct.
Just the name.
And perhaps that's what unsettled me most.
Not the magenta. Not the yellow blueprints. Not even the strange intimacy of being told I was someone's color.
It was how little of the dream I could bring back with me, and how completely that one thing remained.
I've spent so much of my life trying to make sense of things. People. Patterns. Relationships. The peculiar ways we find ourselves returning to places we thought we'd already left.
I build structures around what I observe. I pull things apart. I look for the pieces that don't fit, because those are usually the ones worth examining.
But there are things I cannot pull apart without losing something of the experience itself.
I don't know what the blueprints were for. I don't know why they were yellow. I don't know whether magenta meant anything beyond what it meant in that moment.
And I don't know why his name was waiting for me when I woke.
What I keep thinking about is that distinction between being pulled out and being found. Because I have spent an extraordinary amount of time looking for things. Answers. Explanations. The missing pieces.
And sometimes, despite all that searching, something simply finds me.
I don't know whether that's what happened in my dream.
But I know what it felt like.
And I know where I've felt it before.